Metro
Supreme Court Reserves Judgment On N3.5bn Paris Club Fraud
Published
1 year agoon
By
Editor
The Supreme Court of Nigeria has reserved judgment in an appeal on the final forfeiture of the sum of N1.2bn, brought before it by Melrose General Services Limited, until June 7, 2024.
The appellant is challenging the judgment of the Court of Appeal in May 2019, ordering the forfeiture of the sum, being proceeds of unlawful activity in the Paris Club fund, involving Melrose General Services Limited.
This was made known in a statement by the EFCC’s Head of Media and Publicity, Dele Oyewale, on Thursday.
Counsel for the appellant, Kehinde Ogunwumiji, while informing the apex court of a motion seeking the setting aside of the judgment of the Court of Appeal, noted that the money involved in the forfeiture suit was not a proceed of any unlawful activity, but payment for a contractual and consultancy agreement.
READ ALSO: Confusion As EFCC Joins Kogi Ex-gov, Bello In Amended N100bn Corruption Case
Counsel for the EFCC however, informed the court of his counter-affidavit dated March 11, 2024, praying the court to adopt his brief of argument and dismiss the appeal of the appellant.
The statement reads in part “My Lords, we seek the leave of your noble Lordships to undertake a brief overview of the concept of forfeiture granted by the two courts below in a bid to drive home the 1st respondent`s case. There are generally two types of forfeitures used to recover the proceeds and instrumentalities of crimes. They share the same objective, namely the forfeiture of the state of the proceeds and instrumentalities of crime. Both share common two-fold rationales.”
Arguing further, he stressed that, “Recall that appellant filed his notice of appeal against the well-considered judgment of the Federal High Court which was equally dismissed by the Court of Appeal on May 31, 2019, having found that the appellant failed to show that the said funds are not proceeds of crime.
READ ALSO: EFCC Arrests 45 Suspected Internet Fraudsters In Lagos
“Further to the background of the matter, the EFCC carried out investigations which revealed among others, that the sum of N3.5bn was fraudulently paid to the appellant to carry out a consultancy job for the Nigerian Governors Forum, NGF, under the guise that the appellant carried out a consultancy job for the NGF entitling it to the money when it did not do any such work. The appellant made several withdrawals within a short time leaving N1,222,384,857.84 before the EFCC intervened.
“Further investigation led to the recovery of an additional sum of N220m which the appellant had paid to WASP Networks Ltd and Thebe Wellness Services”.
After listening to all the submissions, the five-man panel of the apex court reserved judgment on the matter till June 7, 2024.
You may like
Court Convicts DHL Franchise Owner In Benin For Conversion Of Customers’ Parcels
Court Grants Two CBEX Promoters N10m Bail Each
EFCC Investigates 18 Sitting Governors
I Saw My Wife’s Lover’s Boxers, Trousers, Shirts In Our Bedroom, Man Tells Court
My Husband Always Throws Out Suitcases, Other Belongings, Insults My Parents —Wife
My Husband Accused Me Of Infidelity; Beat Me Black And Blue —Wife
Metro
Court Convicts DHL Franchise Owner In Benin For Conversion Of Customers’ Parcels
Published
4 hours agoon
July 22, 2025By
Editor
A Magistrate Court sitting in Benin City, Edo State, has convicted Mr. Nuhu Omokide, a franchise owner and manager of a branch of DHL in Benin City, on a five-count charge bordering on conspiracy to steal, stealing, and unlawful interference with property.
Mr. Omokide, who was arraigned in Charge No. MEG/275c/2023/A, was convicted on Tuesday, July 22nd by Afe Osamudiamen, (Chief Magistrate Grade I), under Sections 412(1)(2), 287(1)(b)(c), and 346 of the Criminal Law of Edo State, 2022.
The charge followed allegations that Mr. Omokide criminally converted a parcel containing original academic certificates and other sensitive documents belonging to his customers.
The parcel was submitted at DHL’s Airport Road Office in Benin City in July 2023 for onward delivery to the United Kingdom, but allegedly disappeared under Mr. Omokide’s custody and failed to arrive at its destination.
READ ALSO: Lawyers Drag Tinubu To Court, Seek Emergency Rule In Zamfara
The nominal complainants, frustrated by the defendant’s dismissive and uncooperative attitude, initially reported the matter to the police.
However, Mr. Omokide refused to cooperate with police investigation at the AIG Zone 5 headquarters in Benin City, and instead petitioned the Inspector General of Police, alleging harassment.
The matter was eventually charged to court upon subsequent conclusion of Police investigation.
In his defence, counsel to the defendant, Mr. Razak Isenalumhe, argued that liability for the missing parcel lay with DHL as a corporate entity, not with the defendant personally.
READ ALSO: Court Orders Final Forfeiture Of N335m, Hospital, Five Filling Stations To FG
However, the prosecuting counsel, Festus Usiobaifo, Esq., Principal State Counsel, submitted that where a company is involved in criminal conduct, its alter ego, including the manager, can be held personally liable if they directly committed, aided, or abetted the offence.
Usiobaifo argued that the defendant, having admitted operational control, responsibility, and close proximity to the parcel, could not hide under the corporate veil of DHL to avoid criminal liability.
He, therefore, urged the court to pierce the corporate veil, stressing that corporate cover must never be allowed to shield criminal misconduct, especially where trust is wilfully breached.
Delivering his judgment, Chief Magistrate Osamudiamen agreed with the prosecution and convicted the defendant on all five counts.
READ ALSO: Bank Fraud: Court Orders Forfeiture Of Cash, Properties
The Court held that company executives and managerial officers will be held personally accountable for criminal acts carried out in the course of their duties, and that corporate protection cannot extend to shield criminality.
The judgment has been described by legal observers as timely and significant, especially in the face of growing concerns over the misuse of entrusted property by courier agents.
“It sends a clear signal that courier personnel are custodians of public trust, and any act of criminal conversion or breach of duty will attract the full weight of the law.”
Thereafter, stakeholders in the logistics and delivery industry were advised to draw lessons from the judgment, adding that the era where managerial negligence or deliberate conversion is masked by corporate identity is over.

The Federal High Court in Abuja on Monday granted bail to two detained promoters of Crypto Bridge Exchange in the sum of N10 million each, with two sureties each in like sum.
Justice Mohammed Umar granted bail to Avwerosuo Otorudo and Chukwuebuka Ehirim, with the condition that the sureties must own property worth the bail sum within the jurisdiction of the court.
He further ordered that the addresses of the sureties be verified by the court registrar.
CBEX is a digital platform that became defunct after collecting billions of naira from investors.
Following widespread public outcry after the platform mysteriously disappeared along with investors’ funds, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission approached Justice Emeka Nwite on April 24, seeking an order to arrest and detain six CBEX promoters over alleged fraud.
Justice Nwite granted the request after the EFCC filed an ex parte motion. He ruled that the suspects be detained pending the conclusion of investigations and potential prosecution.
The six suspects named in the application are Adefowora Abiodun, Adefowora Oluwanisola, Emmanuel Uko, Seyi Oloyede, Avwerosuo Otorudo, and Chukwuebuka Ehirim, listed as 1st to 6th defendants respectively.
In the motion ex parte dated April 23, and filed by EFCC counsel, Fadila Yusuf, the Commission stated four grounds for its application. Yusuf noted that the EFCC has a statutory mandate to prevent and detect financial crimes through investigations.
READ ALSO:ICRC Warns Of Rising Malnutrition As North-East Faces Food Shortages
She submitted that “the defendants are at large and a warrant of arrest is required to apprehend them for proper investigation and prosecution.”
According to an affidavit filed in support of the motion, the EFCC said it received intelligence in April 2025 about an alleged investment scheme fraud involving the defendants.
It alleged that the defendants and their company, ST Technologies International Limited, used another company, Crypto Bridge Exchange, to carry out the fraudulent scheme.
The EFCC stated that the defendants promised unrealistic returns on investments—up to 100 per cent.
“That the victims were made to convert their digital assets into a stablecoin, USDT, for onward deposit into the suspects’ crypto wallet.
“That the victims were initially given full access to the platform to monitor their investments.
“That after deposits valued at over one billion dollars were made, the CBEX investment platform became inaccessible, and the victims could no longer withdraw their funds.
“That the victims later discovered that the said scheme was a scam.
“That during the course of investigation, it was discovered that ST Technologies International Limited, though registered with the Corporate Affairs Commission, was not licensed by the Securities and Exchange Commission to operate as an investment firm.
READ ALSO:CBEX Fraud: EFCC Declares Two More Wanted
“That it was also revealed that the defendants had vacated their last known addresses in Lagos and Ogun States.”
The EFCC stated that a warrant of arrest was necessary to place the defendants on the red watch list to facilitate their apprehension and prosecution.
The Commission asserted that its investigation established a prima facie case of investment fraud and that granting the application would serve the interest of justice.
Following the court’s order, Adefowora Abiodun (1st defendant), Avwerosuo Otorudo (5th defendant), and Chukwuebuka Ehirim (6th defendant) were detained in EFCC custody for investigation.
The trio applied for bail before Justice Nwite on June 30, but the application was denied.
In his ruling, Justice Nwite held that from the totality of the affidavit evidence presented by both parties, the weight of evidence against the defendants was strong.
He also noted that, due to the nature of the case, the EFCC had obtained a remand order from a competent court.
Meanwhile, Otorudo and Ehirim filed a separate bail application before Justice Umar.
At the last hearing on July 7, the court reserved ruling after hearing arguments from their counsel, Justice Otorudo, and opposition from EFCC counsel, Fadila Yusuf.
READ ALSO:CBEX Resumes Operations Despite SEC Ban, N1.2tn EFCC Probe
In delivering his ruling on Monday, Justice Umar granted bail to the duo but adjourned the matter until October 13, for the commencement of trial.
The two defendants were arraigned by the EFCC on an amended three-count charge, marked FHC/ABJ/CR/216/2025, bordering on illegal financial operations and unlicensed investment activities.
They were accused of collecting public funds and promising up to 88 per cent returns on investment without obtaining the necessary regulatory approval.
In a separate proceeding, the EFCC arraigned the 1st defendant, ST Technologies International Limited, and its Managing Director, Adefowora Abiodun (2nd defendant), on an amended eight-count charge dated July 9 and marked FHC/ABJ/CR/215/2025.
Justice Umar fixed July 25 for ruling on Abiodun’s bail application after hearing submissions following the defendants’ arraignment.
The charges include allegations of obtaining money by false pretence, money laundering, and operating a financial institution without a licence from the Central Bank of Nigeria or registration with the SEC.
The defendants pleaded not guilty to the amended charges.
Defence counsel, Babatunde Busari, informed the court of a bail application filed on behalf of Abiodun on June 30 and urged the court to grant bail on liberal terms.
Busari argued that the charges were bailable and that Abiodun had voluntarily submitted himself to the EFCC for investigation.
READ ALSO:EFCC Arrests TikToker For Spraying, Stepping On Naira Notes In Kaduna
He also presented a medical report showing that the defendant had an urgent eye condition requiring surgery, which he had been unable to access during 80 days in detention.
“We, therefore, urge the court to admit the defendant to bail, noting that the total monetary value of the claims is around N20 million,” Busari said.
He prayed the court to release Abiodun to him for the purpose of bail.
However, EFCC counsel, Fatsuma Mohammed, strongly opposed the bail application, citing a counter-affidavit filed on July 7.
She urged the court to refuse bail and instead order an expeditious trial, stating that investigation was concluded and the prosecution was ready.
When asked by the judge whether the offence was bailable, Mohammed responded: “The section under which the defendant is charged carries a sentence of seven years upon conviction, which is sufficient to create a flight risk.”
Justice Umar subsequently adjourned the matter to July 25, for ruling and ordered that Abiodun remain in EFCC custody pending the outcome of the bail application.
(PUNCH)

The Kebbi State Police Command has arrested a 30-year-old suspect over the alleged murder of one Auwal Umaru, of Katami village, Silami Local Government Area of Sokoto State.
The spokesperson for the command, Nafi’u Abubakar, made this known in a statement issued in Birnin Kebbi on Monday.
He said that on July 21 at 8am, the police received information that Umaru was seen lying in a pool of blood behind the Central market, Birnin Kebbi.
READ ALSO:2027: Supporting Tinubu Would Sustain Peace, Stability, Development In Niger Delta – Otuaro
“Upon receiving the report, the Divisional Police Officer, Central Market, mobilised a team of policemen and vigilantes to the scene and evacuated the victim to Sir Yahaya Memorial Hospital, Birnin Kebbi, where a medical practitioner certified the victim dead.
“Following a credible lead, one Bello Amakwa, 30, of Birnin Kebbi was arrested in connection with the case.
“In the course of preliminary investigation, the suspect confessed to having stabbed the deceased with a knife on his neck as a result of a mere argument at about 2:30 a.m.,” Abubakar said.
READ ALSO:Bill To Establish Federal Oil And Gas Hospital In Delta Scales Second Reading In Senate
The spokesman said that the exhibits used in committing the crime have also been recovered.
Abubakar quoted the Commissioner of Police, Bello Sani, as appealing to youths not to resort to self-help when aggrieved, but rather to seek redress through appropriate channels.
“He directed the Divisional Police Officer to transfer the case to the State Criminal Investigation Department for a thorough investigation and prosecution,” Abubakar said.
- Wike Backs Edo Gov On Peter Obi Security Clearance
- ‘If Obi Likes, He Should Take My Advice,’ Okpebholo Insist On Security Clearance
- IPF Wants NDDC MD Ogbuku, Others Probed
- Economic Crunch: TETFUND Trains 50 Youth On Broiler Chicken Production In Bauchi
- Gov. Mohammed Begins Renovation Of Bauchi Assembly Complex With N7.8bn
- Court Convicts DHL Franchise Owner In Benin For Conversion Of Customers’ Parcels
- NASS Urged To Governors of Powers Under Land Use Act
- OPINION: Any ‘Appropriate’ Rites Of Passage For Yoruba Kings?
- Make Al-Makura National Chairman Of Our Great Party, APC Group Urges Tinubu, Others
- OPINION: Toru-Ibe State, Aiyedatiwa’s “No Land Ceding” Remark, And The Ondo Ijaw
About Us
Trending
- News4 days ago
How RCCG Pastor Absconded With $8,000, Marry New Wife In US — Pastor Adeboye’s wife
- News4 days ago
‘His Security Is Not Guaranteed,’ Okpehbolo Warns Obi Not To Come To Edo Without Informing Him
- Entertainment4 days ago
Gospel Singer, Eight Others Jailed For Internet Fraud In Kwara
- Politics2 days ago
‘Where’s The 24/7 Electricity You Promised Nigerians,’ ADC Questioned Tinubu
- News3 days ago
Inside £3,500 Per day Elite London Clinic Where Buhari Died
- Politics5 days ago
Why G5 Betrayed Atiku, PDP In 2023 — Ortom
- News1 day ago
PSC Promotes 12 AIGs, 226 Other Senior Police Officers
- News3 days ago
Stolen Jewellery: Patience Jonathan Ex-aides’ Lawyer Laments As Adjournment Hits 42
- Metro3 days ago
Tragedy As Suspect In Ondo Varsity Students’ Murder Dies In Police Custody
- News4 days ago
Why UNIMAID Was Renamed After Buhari – Education Ministry